Post by firoj1616 on Feb 15, 2024 17:12:55 GMT 6
Foreign states retain immunity from jurisdiction. This was Minister Ellen Gracie's understanding, confirmed by the Plenary of the Federal Supreme Court, when rejecting appeals in Union actions against the general consulates of Korea, France and the United States. The processes deal with tax enforcement resulting from fines related to import tax. Minister Ellen Gracie, rapporteur of the action against the Korean consulate, had closed the case, highlighting the understanding established by the Supreme Court that “the foreign state has the immunity from jurisdiction provided for in the Vienna Conventions of 1961 and 1963”. Against this decision, the Union filed an appeal. At the beginning of the appeal trial, Ellen Gracie voted against the Union.
She was accompanied by ministers Eros Grau, Joaquim Barbosa, Cezar Peluso, Gilmar Mendes, Marco Aurélio and Sepúlveda Pertence. Minister Celso de Mello voted in favor of granting the appeal. The trial was interrupted by Minister Carlos Ayres Britto's request for a view. In his opinion, Ayres Britto concluded that immunity from jurisdiction is relative, and not absolute. The minister Egypt Email List defended that the execution process must continue, only to open up to the Union “the opportunity to demonstrate the existence of assets of the executed person located in Brazilian territory, assets that are functionally unlinked from diplomatic and consular activities”. Therefore, he voted in favor of the Union, aligning himself with Celso de Mello's thesis.
Minister Ricardo Lewandowski followed the same understanding, along with Joaquim Barbosa and Cezar Peluso, who reformulated their votes. Minister Cármen Lúcia voted with the rapporteur. Thus, Minister Ellen Gracie's decision achieved a majority and the Plenary dismissed the Appeal.Paulo . Fighting crime The newspaper O Estado de S. Paulo also reports that the fight against the entry of cell phones into State prisons will have as allies modern X-ray equipment and portals that will detect even what is inside the person. The new equipment should arrive within 70 days. The portals are now in the bidding process. Around with a note, they will be paid much more for the product. The inspection also found that, to protect themselves from seizures, traders only keep boxes of products in the boxes and that, once the deal is closed, the devices are searched for in deposits in the parking lot or even in false bottoms inside the stores.
She was accompanied by ministers Eros Grau, Joaquim Barbosa, Cezar Peluso, Gilmar Mendes, Marco Aurélio and Sepúlveda Pertence. Minister Celso de Mello voted in favor of granting the appeal. The trial was interrupted by Minister Carlos Ayres Britto's request for a view. In his opinion, Ayres Britto concluded that immunity from jurisdiction is relative, and not absolute. The minister Egypt Email List defended that the execution process must continue, only to open up to the Union “the opportunity to demonstrate the existence of assets of the executed person located in Brazilian territory, assets that are functionally unlinked from diplomatic and consular activities”. Therefore, he voted in favor of the Union, aligning himself with Celso de Mello's thesis.
Minister Ricardo Lewandowski followed the same understanding, along with Joaquim Barbosa and Cezar Peluso, who reformulated their votes. Minister Cármen Lúcia voted with the rapporteur. Thus, Minister Ellen Gracie's decision achieved a majority and the Plenary dismissed the Appeal.Paulo . Fighting crime The newspaper O Estado de S. Paulo also reports that the fight against the entry of cell phones into State prisons will have as allies modern X-ray equipment and portals that will detect even what is inside the person. The new equipment should arrive within 70 days. The portals are now in the bidding process. Around with a note, they will be paid much more for the product. The inspection also found that, to protect themselves from seizures, traders only keep boxes of products in the boxes and that, once the deal is closed, the devices are searched for in deposits in the parking lot or even in false bottoms inside the stores.